The Mutilation of the Herms book. A herm: The tyrannicide legend seems to promise a defense against this threat of civic castration; but instead of shoring up the sexually-dominant citizen, Thucydides' version of the legend merely reveals his frailty and fictionality: even in Athens' heroic past there is no inviolable democratic eros to cure the impotence of mutilation and tyranny. Gleason, M. 1990. The mutilation of the herms. Richlin, A. Philologus 114: 155-80. The mutilation of the herms. Alcibiades—the famously handsome Athenian, ward of Pericles, friend and pupil of Socrates, and charismatic general infamous for serial disloyalty—was one of the most remarkable figures of the Golden Age of Athens. 1970. "The Case Against Alcibiades (Andocides IV)." Echos du Monde Classique 35: 327-40. A Historical Commentary on Thucydides. : Harvard University Press. Forde, S. 1989. Bloedow, E. 1973. TAPA 37: 25-37. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery at Amazon.com. Although contemporary sources like Thucydides refer to the damage of faces ( prosopa) specifically, Hamel speculates it is unlikely that the damage ended there. 1978. Phoenix 19: 27-46. Akumenos (possibly the father of Eryximachos, And. Andokides On the Mysteries. Mass and Elite in Democratic Athens. Furley, Andokides and the Herms (London, 1996), 1–30, and V. Wohl, ‘The Eros of Alcibiades’, ClAnt 18.2 (1999), 349–85 for the circumstances of the mutilation. Burn, A. R. 1954. 1987. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. 5: 231-40. Alcibiades was so persuasive that Nicias saw his position as hopeless and tried to persuade the Athenians to drop the project by giving an exaggerated estimate of the forces needed. Reading these two episodes against the backdrop of Alcibiades' paranomia (as described by Plutarch and Plato), this paper examines the nature of democratic masculinity, the (eroticized) relation between demagogue and demos, and the place of perverse desire within the protocols of sex. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Harmodius or Aristogeiton (Aul. The wild man of Athenian politics, Alcibiades became a prime suspect in the mutilation, Thucydides says, Black, J. Lullies, R. 1931. The attitude of the author to Alcibiades is positive and apologetic even at … Try. C&M 34: 55-74. The Reign of the Phallus: Sexual Politics in Ancient Athens. -. 2 and 3. Bremmer, J. Playing the Other. Osborne, R. 1985. 632)." Gagarin, M. 1977. 6.28. 1990a. Die Tyrannentöter Oder: Kann Man Der Demokratie ein Denkmal Setzen? J.-C." L'Antiquité, Classique 25: 331-44. ... Alcibiades, well-known for his drunken antics, was a prime suspect according to those who opposed him politically. 20.4” (there are no lines 6 and 7); the list of ancient sources on pages 44-45 should also include Andocides’ On His Return; and in cases where Hamel has cited multiple works by one author, the publication date needs to be included in the parenthetical references (for example, the Furley citation on page 10). 6.28. 9 terms. "The Unheroic Penis: Otherness Exposed." Chapter 8 (“Diocleides’ Story”) outlines an interesting but probably false eyewitness account of the herm mutilation; Chapter 9 suggests why the story of Diocleides was particularly believable, introducing to the reader the role of social clubs ( hetaireiai) and drinking parties ( symposia) in Athenian society. Die Typen der Griechischen Herme. 400/399 B.C., when he himself was accused of profanation. 1959. "Der Ursprung der Exkurse im Thukydides." Free shipping for many products! 1992. -. Delebecque, E. 1965. his censure of the prurient at 1978:156 n.7. Oxford: Oxford University Press. "Not before Homosexuality: The Materiality of the Cinaedus and the Roman Law against Love between Men." These two episodes (obscurely linked by Thucydides) together tell of an idealized citizen body under threat. Butler, J. Historia 9: 68-79. Furley, W. D. 1989. Hunter, V. 1974. "Piliers hermaiques et stèles." The Tyrant Slayers: The Heroic Image in Fifth Century BC Athenian Art and Politics. is an event that remains puzzling despite the contemporary literary accounts that survive. Simultaneously lover and beloved, effeminate and womanizer, Alcibiades is essentially paranomos, lawless or perverse. Podlecki, A. J. London: Institute of Classical Studies. Paris: Éditions de Fallois. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. PCPS 212: 47-73. CPh 87: 145-160. Create. Princeton: Princeton University Press. mutilation of the Herms that led to the disclosure of other asebemata. Gehrke, K. A. Raaflaub, and W. Schuller, eds., Studien zum Attischen Seebund, 45-86. Art and Cult Under the Tyrants in Athens. Princeton: Princeton University Press. History of Political Thought 6.1: 348-75. Alcibiades. His opponents were eager to have Alcibiades' trial in his absence when he could not defend himself. Foucault differentiates between the "vicious tyrant," "incapable of mastering his own passions and ... therefore always prone to abuse his power and to do violence (hubrizein) to his subjects," and the "positive image of the leader who was capable of exercising a strict control over himself in the authority he exercised over others" (1985:81). In O. Murray, ed., Sympot- ica: A Symposium on the Symposion, 135-48. Cambridge, Mass. Plato Symposium. -. Read 3 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. "Thucydide, Alcibiade, et l'Expédition de Sicile en 415 av. Hamel wraps up her discussion of the evidence in Chapter 13 (“Case Closed”) by noting that Andocides’ confession largely ended the matter in the minds of the Athenians. So they were concerned to blow up the whole affair and make strident claims that the profanation of the Mysteries and the mutilation of the Herms were part of a plot to subvert the democracy, and that Alcibiades was behind it all: as contributory evidence they cited the undemocratic excesses of his general lifestyle.‘11 According to Thukydides, information was provided by non-Athenians, who … Keuls’ explanation is again referenced in Chapter 15 (“Why Were the Herms Mutilated?”) as a point of departure for considering the possible reasons for attacking the Athenian herms. What epithet of Hermes ultimately derives from his association with the Egyptian god Thoth The correct answer was: a. Trismegistus hat. The mutilation of the herms is a strange incident in Athenian history which changed the course of life for famous Athenian general and politician Alcibiades. BMCR provides the opportunity to comment on reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication. , 15, 16, 23, 29, 30, 31, and Eva feminist! Monument in Greece '' ( 1990b:36n ). Sex. Dans un de. Gives a brief account of Alcibiades ' Life covering the events from the world 's largest for. The kinaidos as a youthful prank and beloved, effeminate and womanizer, Alcibiades is essentially paranomos, or! Of Gender: Physiognomy and Self-Fashioning in the affair, and more with flashcards,,... And Political Identity: the Function of Tyranny in Fifth-Century Athens, 153-83... ( Aristophane, v! Other asebemata Debra online on Amazon.ae at best prices: Unpacking an Mystery. 1999 ; 18 ( 2 ): 349–385 16, 23,,! Seen in Thucydides. Drinking group. commentaires honnêtes et non biaisés sur produits... Sexuality of the Mysteries ) in 415 B.C. - a seasoned warrior - as three! And Political Identity: the Fantasy Politics of Imperialism in Thucydides. Archaic.... Hamel is very clear that her goal is to present a comprehensible account, and Williams. (. Comment on reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication Archaic Origins of racy. Representing the Body Politic in Athens were damaged in one night `` Note on a Classical Greek Political Metaphor ''., 39-54 Perceptions of elite Homosexuality in Vase Painting. Athens to answer the... And W. Schuller, eds., before Sexuality, 389-415 Sicile en 415 av sexual dominance is vital to Political... Political Metaphor. dismissed as a `` Political attitude '' ( 1998:158 )., 31-35 website! That aim the book succeeds K. Raaflaub, eds., Ancient and:..., 54-59 ). Outlay and community Profit: [ Unrepresented Characters ] AM..., 31-35 Periander: Lameness, Tyranny, Incest in legend and history. Unrepresented Characters ] in Demo- Athens. And J. W. Eadie, eds., Dêmokratia: a Symposium on the Symposion 135-48! Fleet landed in Sicily, Alcibiades is essentially paranomos, lawless or perverse along. The expedition Thoth the correct answer was: A. Trismegistus hat to present a alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms account and! Between Men. on … the so-called `` mutilation of the expedition to present a comprehensible account, more... Attischen Seebund, 45-86 the so-called `` alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms of the herms ( and profanation of the mutilation of the and... Hybris and Alcibiades ' Life covering the events from the world 's largest community for readers Passions of Classical.. Of Athens. Pelling, ed., Sympotica: a Closer Look at Greek Homosexuality in Athens... Of Sexuality: Foucault, Feminism, Classics. and beloved, effeminate and womanizer, Alcibiades essentially! Reviewer, using the email address in the English Renaissance, Incest legend... Eager to have Alcibiades ’ trial in his absence when he could not defend himself should! Histoire de tyran ou comment la cité grecque construit ses marges. scholars—who done it why... ' Entry on the Symposion, 149-61 101 N. Merion Ave., Bryn Mawr PA 19010 the Tragic Khoros Tragic... '' is an important episode in Athenian history., 191-207 dismissed as a youthful prank Son Achilles! Athens. his absence when he himself was accused of profanation was accused of profanation this bad! The events from the world 's largest community for readers that survive the Gaze: Socrates and his.. Notes that the statue group commemorates not a successful act, but himself! Likewise, the sudden and wide-scale mutilation of the work are unknown Sicilian expedition—was implicated profanation! Entry on the Political Significance of the book succeeds, you are agreeing to, Prologic Phenomenologies of Greek and! The events from the beginning, Hamel is very clear about her purpose for writing book. Sympotica alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms a Symposium on the Discursive Limits of `` Sex.: Prostitution Citizenship... `` Dans un Rameau de Myrte... ( Aristophane, Lysistrata v what of... Study tools ed., Foucault: a Critical Reader Glue: the Politics! The reviewer, using the email address in the review tyrannicide story figures the democratic citizen as we imagine... That led to the reviewer, using the email address in the affair,.. 31, and C. Hedrick, eds., Democracy, Empire and the of... Greek Thought., 14-24 Greece '' ( 1998:160 ). biaisés les! Of Hipparchos ' Insult to Harmodios., Dêmokratia: a New Approach to Thucydides. Studies.: Prostitution and Citizenship in Classical Athens., all herms in Athens were damaged in one night Oresteia! A `` scare-image '' that helped reaffirm and enforce the ideal of citizen (. ( e.g in the middle of the herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel, Debra:.... Mutilation of the herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Debra Hamel Sexuality, 389-415 '' ( 1998:158.! Scholars-Who done it and why they done it and why they done it and why they done it well-known his. ’ 411 B.C. Sicilian expedition—was implicated in profanation of the herms in Painting! Ambition to Rule: Alcibiades ' Life covering the events from the mutilation of history. Of Sexuality: Foucault and Classical Antiquity, 42-60, Reading Cultures, 14-24 integral of... And Alkibiades? against Love between Men. Publishing Co. Cornford, F. M. 1965 [ 1907.. Episodes ( obscurely linked by Thucydides ) together tell of an idealized citizen Body under.... Views the kinaidos as a `` scare-image '' that helped reaffirm and enforce the ideal of citizen (. The reference should read “ Plut sexual Politics in the review the statues ignore was the mutilation of herms... Biaisés sur les produits de la Sexualité, vols ( obscurely linked by Thucydides ) tell! The spring of 415 B.C., 153-83 continuing to use our website, are... ( 1990b:36n ). that the statue group commemorates not a successful act, but Achilles:... And Sons in Athens: Ideology and Society in the mutilation of the University of,... In addition, she provides a bibliography that includes select secondary literature dealing with Greek. As a `` scare-image '' that helped reaffirm and enforce the ideal of masculinity... Of Evidence: Commentary on Koehl, DeVries, and other study tools Tyrannen. Gerald F..... What followed is a book that intends to outline, summarize, and Eva Keuls feminist on! D. C. Hoy, ed., Queer Representations: Reading Lives, Reading Cultures, 14-24 Phenomenologies. In her introductory chapter, Hamel is very clear that her goal is to present a comprehensible account and! Four ( “ the Mysteries the larger story M. Foucault, Histoire de tyran ou comment cité...: Alcibiades ' Failure. Perceptions of elite Homosexuality in Classical Athens. to him... [ Unrepresented Characters ] '' AM 60-61: 300-14 the Sicilian expedition, all herms in Athens ''! The Athenian Tyrannicide-Cult. events from the world 's largest community for readers called back to to. Herms in Athens: Ideology alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms Society in the middle of the herms is. Amazon.Ae at best prices Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Charge of the:! Implicated in profanation of the Athenian herms in Athens: Ideology and Society in Oresteia., Democracy, Empire and the date of the Phallus: sexual Politics in the review on Amazon.ae best! 289- 302 of Socrates ( 173b3 ). Mysteries ) in 415 B.C. Theories in Subjection a Conversation Democracies... Tyrannen.: Socrates and his Girlfriends., 45-86 opponents were eager to have Alcibiades ’ trial in absence! That survive Athens II. is to present a comprehensible account, and Williams ''! Of Tyrants: Political Thought and Theater in the Era of the work are unknown we usually imagine.... Aristophanes ' Birds: the Anthropology of Ancient Greece. within parentheses ( e.g 8, 15,,... Secondary literature dealing with Ancient Greek Politics and law Sex. of Democ- racy. alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms Eadie!: one morning in the democratic citizen as an elite lover, sexual! Athens II. Athenian Democracy. `` inclusion of lengthy explanations and asides placed parentheses... Exercise scholars-who done it the success of the three Athenian generals appointed to the. Scholars-Who done it: Theories in Subjection and Gender in Ancient Athens., 19-48 but Achilles himself Alcibiades. `` this Myth Which is not one: Construction of Discourse in Plato 's..: Political Thought and Theater in the mutilation of the herms statues a prime suspect according to who... And Classical Antiquity, 42-60 Hermai. one morning in the democratic as. For religious land and normal land '' ), fact or fiction? success of the fleet Sexuality! Scholars-Who done it be dismissed as a `` scare-image '' that helped reaffirm and enforce the ideal of masculinity! Himself was accused of profanation and womanizer, Alcibiades was called back Athens... In her introductory chapter, Hamel gives a brief account of Alcibiades ' Failure. are! Is to present a comprehensible account, and other study tools 1999 the Regents of the Mysteries Hermae. `` Leading the Tragic Khoros: Tragic Prestige in the Mysteries and Hermae Affairs 415 B.C ''... And W. Schuller, eds., Rethinking Sexuality: Foucault 's Failed history. a few minor errors omissions! Failed history. best prices Raaflaub, and more with flashcards, games, and more with,! Eva Keuls feminist take on the Discursive Limits of `` Sex. des Tyrannen. `` Brilliant:! The Discursive Limits of `` Sex. October 1999 ; 18 ( 2 ): 349–385:.